Part 66: Relationships are Eternal

Once you are in a relationship with someone, you will always be in a relationship with that person. It’s like the Hotel California, you can never leave. I don’t care if you never speak to her again, if you move to the other side of the world, put up a dartboard with her face on it, refer to her only as, The Bitch; you will always be in relationship. There will always be a corner of your brain, I dare say, a corner of your heart, that has her name on it.

This is doubly true if you are in photos in Facebook together. This is triply true if she met your parents. It’s quadruply true if you were married. It’s doubly, triply, quadruply true if you have kids together. You are hitched.

Love may not be eternal, but relationship is. The legal end of a marriage is not the end of a relationship.

Relationship, at its minimal level, means that your partner rents space in your head. You think of him sometimes, happily or unhappily, with fondness or regret. He’s part of your story and you are part of his. You have to account for him if you’re honest. You’ll be flooded with memories, good or bad, after the most trivial cues. He will affect the way you relate to anyone else. He will be an item to compare and contrast.

Former relationships rarely exist at this minimal level. Usually there are more feelings. Many more. They may be negative feelings. You might hate her, but there will still be feelings. At some point, time and time again, for the rest of your life, after the right buttons are pushed, you will be transported by your passions.

You’ve seen this in others. You’ve had beers with the man who, at the mere mention of his ex, goes on a ten minute tirade about the shrew. You’ve drained a bottle of wine with a friend who combs over every detail of her ex’s pervasive perfidy. These are people still in relationship even though their divorces are final.

By the way, love and hate are not that far apart. They are both intense. They are both very, very far away from indifference. You’ll never be indifferent about a former partner, no matter how hard you try to fake it.

If you agree that you will always be in relationship, then the question is: what kind of relationship will it be?

The Shrink’s Links: Should I Stay or Should I Go?

 

Bringing you the best of mental health every week.

Ball and chain

I picked up Should I Stay or Should I Go? hoping that I might find an algorithm for divorce or reconciliation, some kind of formula in which one could plug in factors and come away with an inarguable conclusion about how much effort couples should put into marriage counseling. Every single couple I have ever met has asked for something like that. Alas, no one, who I can find, has written that book yet.

What Lundy Bancroft and JAC Patrissi have written is a book for long-suffering wives who are having a hard time deciding whether or not to leave their no-good husbands. There are plenty of no-good husbands, so I’m sure it’s a best seller. I think it’s fair to say there are more no-good husbands than no-good wives. However, many of the latter exists and, in most cases, they are married to each other. There is no good reason their book could not be read by long-suffering husbands of no-good wives, except the authors didn’t write it that way. A bias is revealed.

This book is chock-full of provocative questions to get the long-suffering wives of no-good husbands to think of all the angles they need before they settle for less from their husbands than they deserve. Their book has been one of my chief sources for my When Illness takes Over series. For this, I am indebted.

Still, while you are asking provocative questions, couldn’t Bancroft and Patrissi have asked these long-suffering wives of no-good husbands how they contributed to the marital problems? Can’t they turn their incisive insight on themselves?

Click here to go to the book’s website

Relationships, part 65: Can It, Should It, Be Saved?

sexual boredomShould you be in this relationship to begin with?

Related questions are: Is it worth it to work so hard to save a relationship? Aren’t some beyond help? Might it be better to scrap it and start over somewhere else? What if you sacrifice everything to save your relationship, admit your faults, learn to listen, start therapy, quit all your bad habits and change into the person your partner wants you to be, and he doesn’t make his own changes? Will it be worth it or would you have become a better person for nothing?

Yes, it would be worth it, but let’s go on.

You say all your friends are telling you to leave. He’s a loser. There’re plenty of fish in the sea. Your parents claim they never liked him anyway. You regret ever getting involved with him. Wouldn’t it be easier to give up on relationships entirely and live out your life single and celibate?

Then, in the next breath, you say something I’ve heard time and time again, even in the most dysfunctional situations. You say it,

“But I still love him.”

I ask, but you are not sure what you mean.

What should you do? Can your marriage be saved?

I believe it can, in a manner of speaking. Any marriage can be saved, depending on what you mean by marriage.

The boundaries of the legal institution of marriage do not correspond directly to the concerns of the heart. There are plenty of people deeply in love who are not married and plenty of people married who are not and never have been in love. Furthermore, the language of the heart does not even correspond directly with the feelings of the heart.

The institution of marriage has changed greatly through history. In our own time, in much of the United States, we’ve seen it expand to include gay marriage. In the last two generations, women have risen to have equal rights within marriage. There is more cohabitating; more marriages between members of different races, ethnic groups, and religions; more divorces freely given; and more remarriages and shuffling and re-shuffling of child custody. Wives are almost as likely to earn as much as their husbands as the other way around. Guys are taking care of children and doing the laundry, although, perhaps not as much as they should to be equitable.

You would have had to have been living under a rock not to have noticed the revolution. The pace of this social change is probably accelerated, but the changes have gone on for centuries. Go back a couple hundred years and arranged marriage was the norm, as it often is in some countries today. Go back a couple thousand years and many men had more than one wife. Clearly, the human institution of marriage has many, many manifestations. Give us some more time, I think we will think of many more.

So, on one hand, you have the legal institution of marriage, codified and circumscribed by family, tradition, and religious authorities, like property lines in the middle of the sea. Then, on the other hand, you have the spiritual, or if you prefer, emotional, side. One is the map, the other is the territory. The one is in constant need of revision, it’s always out of date; the other is eternal, inviolable, and holy.

Spiritual people have, forever, testified to the sacred bonds of marriage. I don’t think they were referring to the forms of marriage that civil authorities legislate, or even the proclamations that lovers make. I think they’re talking about this other side, the part that is beyond words and defies explanation.

Stay tuned to the next post as I try to explain it.

The Shrink’s Links: The Human Magnet Syndrome

Bringing you the best of mental health every week.

Chain3

Why might you be attracted to people who hurt you? What can you do about it?

Ross Rosenberg gives an answer to the first question in his book, The Human Magnet Syndrome. As for the second: you just have to leave them and then not hook up with anyone like them again.

His answer to the first question is found in his Continuum of Self Theory. It goes like this: people vary in the degree to which they are self-centered versus oriented towards others. Most fall in the middle in a kind of a bell curve distribution. The people in the extreme ends of the tails tend to find each other. A self-centered type has obvious reasons to hook up with a selfless individual. He wants someone to take care of him. The selfless individual needs someone to take care of. It seems to be a match made in heaven, until it isn’t. Then the selfless ones have all kinds of trouble convincing themselves to leave.

I have the same problem with this theory as I do of all theories that are based on personality typologies. I don’t believe personality typologies exist. People will only fit neatly into types until you get to know them, then they don’t fit at all, unless you grow to despise them, then they fit in types again. The real reason to have typologies is so that you can dismiss people.

That, of course, is the purpose of the book. It is written for all those long suffering people in toxic relationships who are too loving to ever leave. The author succeeds in turning the abusive partners into monsters: sociopaths and narcissists, so the loving partner can rid herself of them and not feel guilty doing so.

Is this the best we can do?

Click here to go to the book’s website

The Shrink’s Links: CrowdMed

Bringing you the best of mental health every week.

Do you have frustratingly complex medical symptoms that have you and your doctors baffled?

Pay $199, submit your medical history anonymously to CrowdMed, and dozens, or even hundreds, of “medical detectives” will chime in. You get a list of suggestions, based on these detective’s rankings, to share with your doctor.

Do you have medical knowledge and want to sharpen your diagnostic skills?

Look over the cases submitted. Share your assessment. As feedback comes in from patients, your reputation rises, or falls, you learn more about medicine, and may even make some money.

Why should you trust a group of anonymous people, some of whom may have never gone to med school?
I know, it sounds scary. However, you should be scared when you trust just one, who may have gone to med school decades ago and may have never seen your particular problem in all his years of practice.

Click here to find out more.

When Illness Takes Over: How to be a Sentry

 

SentryWhen illness takes over a relationship, it takes hard work to eradicate the intruder and eternal vigilance to keep it away. Relapse can be expected. When we are talking about addiction, it takes an average of seven real attempts before recovery feels solid and, even then, you won’t know if he’s going to need eight. Mental illness also tends to be episodic, and each new episode is worse than the last. People who have succumbed once to the allure of violence, sexual recklessness, self harm, suicide attempts, or self pity are more likely to do it again. Moreover, illness will often go into hiding when it feels threatened, so that what appears to be recovery is really a more pernicious hidden phase of the same madness that troubled you before.

You and your partner are going to want to beef up your security, stake out a perimeter, and set up a few trip wires to activate an alarm if the illness comes close again. Addiction, mental illness, violence, sexual recklessness, self harm, suicide, and the hopeless behavior that accompanies physical illness have such onerous consequences that you’re going to want a warning, so that you can take steps to prevent a reoccurrence. You and your partner are going to need a sentry. And guess what? As the partner not directly affected by the illness, the sentry will probably be you.

Here are your instructions:

Accept your assignment

You might be wondering, why do I have to be the sentry, watching out for her illness? Can’t she look out for it, herself? Ideally, yes, she should be looking out for her own illness. She should understand what triggers her and what loads the gun. She should have a plan to prevent relapse. But the fact of the matter is that she is more vulnerable to it than you are. When the illness tricks, it tricks her first. This particular illness was custom-made just for her, to sneak up in her blind spots. It fits her like a glove. It wasn’t custom made for you, so you can see through the deceptions more easily.

Paid professionals can help, they have the knowledge, they have the objectivity, but they don’t have the access you have. They don’t see your loved one on the weekends and at night when illness often strikes. They also, unlike you, have little to lose.

Can you resign from the security detail? Sure you can, but here’s the thing. The only way to do that is to end the relationship as you know it. We’re talking about divorce. You’ve probably already thought of that. Maybe you’re still thinking, unable to decide. Well, put this on your scale of pros and cons. If you stay, you are going to have to be a sentry, if only to guard your own interests. Are you ready?

Stay awake

Don’t give everyone the impression you are watching out for the illness and then fall asleep on the job. That’s worst than leaving the security detail, altogether. Don’t watch your alcoholic husband like a hawk in the first month of recovery and then forget about it later on. Don’t keep it up just until you get busy. This has got to be a priority. It’s tempting to believe that the hardest part of recovery is the beginning, but that’s often not the case. Many people in early recovery ride on a pink cloud and don’t run into problems until later on. The first anniversary of recovery, for one, is often a critical time. Don’t assume that the illness is only likely to return when things are hard. Sometimes good fortune can trigger it, too. The one thing that you can be certain of is that it will intrude when you are not looking, when you let down your guard and stop watching the door.

Patrol the perimeter

A good sentry doesn’t keep looking in the same place. You should understand how the illness arrived in the past, that’s the main thing to look out for. It is likely to come that way again. If, for instance, your wife gets depressed at Christmas time, then make preparations for Christmas time. Don’t let it catch you off guard. But understand, it can come other ways, as well. Factors present at Christmas that might result in depression any time there is busyness, family contact, alcohol use, overeating, darkness, or an imperative to be merry.

Don’t be deceived

Illness arrives in disguise. No one starts off drinking three six packs a day just to feel normal. No, they start off with a glass of wine at dinner, a beer during the game, or doing a shot with a friend. These things are all good things, there is nothing wrong with any of them in themselves. They are only evil because of where they lead. A good sentry sees through the disguises. Know the masks that your loved one’s illness wears. Talk about their masks with him in advance. Listen to what he knows about it.

My next post, When Illness Takes Cover, will have more about the cloaks illness puts on. Study it well.

Confirm

A good sentry has got to be a little bit jumpy. You’ve got to be vigilant, but keep your finger off the trigger or you’ll shoot a friendly. When you see something that looks like the illness, seek confirmation before conclusion. If your husband keeps driving by that place where he used to score drugs, you should be seeing red flags. This may very well be the way the illness creeps up innocently. Your husband may be getting a contact high from just driving by, but that’ll lead to a real high. He might have already resumed using drugs, but hasn’t admitted it to you yet. You have reasons to be concerned, but don’t go in with guns blazing, accusing him of using drugs. No, get confirmation before you shoot.

One way of doing this is to ask him what it felt like for him to drive by his own drug house. Engage in conversation, not an accusation. If he is using, then he may well give you additional reasons to be concerned. If so, then put the reasons up for confirmation, also.

In the case of chemical use, you and your partner may very well find it helpful to use a home drug or alcohol testing kit to confirm your suspicions. It can provide an objective measure, so that you don’t have to rely on he said or she said. For this, or other kinds of illnesses, you may want to get a second opinion from a professional; sort of like calling in another sentry and asking what she sees. At any rate, ask questions first, and shoot later.

Don’t shine your flashlight in your partner’s eyes

In the past, you may have felt like you were a doormat for the illness to wipe its feet on. Now, you are no longer a doormat, you’re a flashlight. Use yourself as a flashlight to illuminate things, not to shine in your partner’s eyes. In other words, now that you have more awareness and a vital job, use this awareness and your role for the greater good, not to punish your partner or hit him over the head with his transgressions. Now that you are no longer a doormat, don’t start wiping your feet on your partner; it was not him who did all this, it was the illness; and now, by gratuitously punishing your partner, you are behaving no better.

Keep yourself safe

Don’t be so busy being a sentry, watching out for your partner’s illness that you get overcome by your own.

What’s that you say? You don’t have an illness? Everyone has an illness. You may not know what it is yet because it has not grown strong enough to overcome your defenses, but we all get to the point, when under sufficient stress, that the defenses break down. That’s when you discover your own tailor-made demons.

Maybe you know what your illness is. Either it took you over as much as your partner’s illness took over him, or you’ve seen small glimmers of it. If that’s the case, you know what to look out for. Don’t watch for it yourself. Let your partner be your sentry, just as you are his. Watch each others’ backs. He can see it more clearly than you can for the same reasons you are well suited to be his sentry. The only thing is, you have to tell him what to look for.

If you’ve been dealing with your partner’s illness for a long time, you probably worked very hard to keep yourself strong. Someone in the house had to function. The laundry, the cooking, the kids, the relatives, the shopping, and going to work don’t get done by themselves. You haven’t had the luxury of indulging in, or even paying attention to, your feelings. That doesn’t mean you don’t have them. You, too, are at risk. You may not be accustomed to relying on your partner for anything; she just hasn’t been reliable. That’s going to have to change. This is how you learn to trust her again.

There are many cases in which your particular illness makes it difficult for you to be an effective sentry. If you are excitable, paranoid, or pathologically suspicious, for example. Chicken Little and the Boy who Cried Wolf were ineffective sentries; there were just too many false alarms. Then there’s the cases in which his illness creeps up under cover of yours. You know you’re paranoid, so you don’t say anything; your partner, in his illness, accuses you of being paranoid and dismisses your report. It can get really confusing and difficult to know what to think. All the more reason to get independent confirmation. All the more reason to reconsider the terms of your relationship.

Raise the alarm

If you have been doing your duty as a sentry and patrolling the perimeter, there will come a time when you detect the presence of the illness. Then, after you get confirmation, you’re going to have to raise the alarm. You may not want to do it, no one wants to be the bearer of bad news, but this is what you’re there for. If the illness has given the two of you a lot of trouble in the past, you might not want to believe it’s back. If the illness has already taken over your partner, you might get an argument.

When you raise the alarm, follow the regulations on constructive conflict:

· Pick the right time and place

· Start with the easy stuff

· Stay relevant

· Learn something

· Acknowledge feelings

· Call the four fouls of an unfair fight: defamation, defensiveness, stonewalling, and contempt

· Don’t be evil

· Repair injuries

· Detect dreams

· Compromise

· Commemorate what you have accomplished

Go back and re-read my series on constructive conflict (you can click here) if you don’t remember how to follow the regulations.

Remember, relapse is the rule, not the exception. It happens. You don’t want to make it happen, it’ll happen on its own; but, when it does happen, you’ll want to learn something new from the experience, something that you can use against the illness if you take your post as sentry again.

Some Things You May Not Know About Substance Abuse, Part 21: You can’t stop cravings from knocking at the door, but you don’t have to answer

You could stop using whatever it is that is destroying you and you will still think about it from time to time. You’ll have dreams of using. A beer truck might roll by and you’ll feel thirsty. That old life will seem good every now and then. You could have some very good reasons to stop using, but you will forget them if the craving is strong enough. Thoughts of using are just that: thoughts; but they can be very powerful if fed. They can bring down the most secure sobriety.

When people enter recovery and find they cannot stop the thoughts of use, they get discouraged and figure nothing can help; but recovery is a process. You can’t reduce the incidence of thoughts of use without first reducing their duration.

You know those people who walk through your neighborhood in pairs and knock on your door asking you to join their church? I get them in my neighborhood, too. One day, I invited them in for coffee. I gave them donuts. We had a good talk about the Bible, but I couldn’t get them to leave. They next day they were back. I didn’t want to be rude, so we had coffee again, and again, and again, and again. They were good people, but I wasn’t going to join their church, I was already set in that regard. I was wasting their time and mine also. I couldn’t make them stop. It was madness.

Then, one day when they knocked, I made an excuse that I was painting the kitchen, so we couldn’t have coffee. They were back a few minutes later in old clothes and offered to help me paint. Since I wasn’t really painting anything, I had to tell them the truth. Please don’t knock on my door anymore. Goodbye.
The next day, they were back.

Eventually, I learned that even engaging with them in the doorway was a mistake. Whenever I would hear the doorbell, I had to peer out a window. If it was them, I’d make like I was not home. Finally, they stopped coming.

Your cravings to use drugs are like that. So are your anxieties, your negative thoughts, your unwarranted feelings, your paranoia, and any of your impulses to do things that you’ll regret. You can’t stop these thoughts from knocking at the door, but you don’t have to let them in.

When you notice you’re engaging in these thoughts, that’s the time to stop them. Say to yourself, “Stop the Madness”, and those thoughts will stop for the moment you say it. Seriously. All you have to do is identify your thing as madness for you to end the power it has over you for that moment. It’s as simple as that.

Oh, the thoughts of use will come back in, like, two seconds; so soon it’ll seem like you never stopped. It’s simple, but often it’s not easy. Sometimes thoughts of use have already moved in, are sleeping on the couch, or even kicked you out of your own bed, or are holding you hostage. They’ll dig in their heels, argue, threaten, lie, hornswoggle you into believing you need to use. Getting rid of them will be like when a woodchuck chews his own leg off to get out of a trap, but it all starts with you identifying the madness.
So, do it again. Say, “Stop the Madness”, and those thoughts stops once more. Do this as many times as it takes. You will reduce the duration of thoughts of use. Time spent in thoughts of use will get shorter and shorter. You’ll get better at doing this. It’ll get easier for you to stop. Eventually, you’ll learn to see the thoughts of use coming and, like me, pretend you’re not home.

I was complicit with the people knocking on my door, but I didn’t know it. I had a choice. I didn’t need to let them in. I entertained them. I fed them. I sat with them and had coffee.

When you stop answering the door every time your thoughts of use knock, you’ll see you have a choice, too. You’ve been complicit. The sooner you terminate your engagement with thoughts of use, the sooner they lose their power over you. They wither away, malnourished. You’ll see.